[DJKapeesh]

So I'm looking at selling my 1er after doing 2 months of warranty and personal maintenance / fixing leading up to when I got the car back 100% for 2 days to only end up getting rear ended on Halloween night.

Pictures attached of damage and no damage for comparison.

That being said I'm just looking to get rid of the car and payment at this point and downgrade to something cheaper I can pay off in about 6 months. Car is available if anyone is interested as of right now.

The main point:
I started looking for possible replacement vehicles and I came across 2 vehicles at a local broker.

1# 1998 S52 Z3M with 75k miles (asking $9000)
2# 2006 Z4M Roadster 120k miles (asking $11500)

My question here is which of these cars (if any) is better value and worth looking at? My requirements are something fun, under 12k (cheaper is better) and won't require excessive maintenance and repairs.

I have had a BMW 325ci 2004 w/ ASA ProCharger before and the maintenance was very reasonable (with the exception of the $2000 clutch replacement)

Any insight about these vehicles would be great.
Other cars I am entertaining are MR2 toyota, RX7 (I know, completely unreliable), S2000, G35, and some others.