Just thought I'd finish this thread off. I never really got very good shots of the car, but here's what it looked like when I brought it in to get fixed.
Before 1. (Here you can see the largest cut on the left grill and can kinda see the wrinkle in the paint on the right edge of the left grill)
Before 2. (Here you can kinda see the cut on the top of the right grill.)
This is what it looked like when I arrived to pick it up.
This is the little spot where the paint was missing (looks like there may have been a hair on it when it was painted).
After the worked it some more.
Closeup of where the missing paint was.
Closeup of the slightly off reflector.
Thread complete.