Option 4 - go local and get a set of
superspeeds. I run the 18x9.5 as my street wheels and for CAD$1K with tax, they're almost nice as my forged track wheel set for 1/4 the price.
If you want a dedicated, truly beater winter wheel set, DM me, I have a set of 17"s with tires that I can't use now that I have the PFC big brakes all around