|
|
SUPPORT ZPOST BY DOING YOUR TIRERACK SHOPPING FROM THIS BANNER, THANKS! |
Post Reply |
|
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
10-18-2013, 08:42 AM | #1 |
Bad Lieutenant
233
Rep 3,517
Posts |
BMW modifies oil recommendation for M engines
I'm sure many have seen this by now, but I thought I'd bring it to light in the event some have passed it up.
Many are reading this as: " you now have a choice " ... apparently some dealerships are asking customers when they come in for M car service but I think those are ghost stories. I read this like the owner's manual: if TWS isn't available, you are also allowed to use these now-recommended 5w-30. The discussion at m3post is alluding to the tight clearances of the rod bearings, combined with the 60 weight oil, as to the early demise of the rod bearings. Also, the rod bearing was changed to a much harder material > 2011, but the clearances were not modified. BMW has done some interesting things here. Either way, here's the information in case you haven't seen it.
__________________
02 E39M5 | TiAg/Schwartz | Tubi Rumore | Ultimate Ti Pedals | E60 SSK | Jim Blanton 3.45 40/100% | Coby Alcantara | StrongStrut STB
|
10-18-2013, 11:52 AM | #2 |
Mechanical Engineer
96
Rep 1,025
Posts |
That is kind of strange, and I'm inclined to agree with you.
I'd really like to know why they went form 10w60 all the way to 5w30 as the alternate. There are plenty of weights in between. Mobil1 makes 5w40 for sure, and I think I've also seen Mobil1 10w40 and 5w50. Why not recommend those (obviously closer) weights? Do they really have that much loyalty to castrol? |
Appreciate
0
|
10-18-2013, 01:38 PM | #4 |
Colonel
1567
Rep 2,665
Posts |
The "only use Castrol 10W60 and no other brand of the same weight " seems really suspect when they also throw in that 5W30 Castrol is also allowed.
How much does Castrol pay for this?
__________________
2006 Z4M Coupe - Stromung exhaust, ZHP knob, stubby antenna, clutch delay delete
|
Appreciate
0
|
10-18-2013, 05:42 PM | #5 |
Second Lieutenant
13
Rep 279
Posts |
So which oil should I use?
__________________
06 Alpinweiss Z4M R Anthracite Apex EC-7 9F/9.5R, 245/275 Super Sport's, 17" Kosei K1 255/40r17 Direzza II, SS Lines, Pagid RS29, Ate SuperBlue, VT Comp. MM's, RE trans. mounts, AST 4150, Swift springs, Vorschlag camber plates, RE RSM, H&R swaybars, spherical rtabs, SuperFlex poly fcabs, StrongStrut Braces, Euro Headers, Stromung exhaust, ESS Tune, Eventuri intake |
Appreciate
0
|
10-18-2013, 05:56 PM | #6 |
Bad Lieutenant
233
Rep 3,517
Posts |
It seems the oil you may chose could very well depend on how the car is driven. The Ford mustang equipped with the track package calls for 5w-50, while the non track pack equipped vehicle uses 5w-20/5w-30 IIRC. There really is no difference aside from an oil cooler, unless someone knows of other mods to the track package in regards to the engine.
__________________
02 E39M5 | TiAg/Schwartz | Tubi Rumore | Ultimate Ti Pedals | E60 SSK | Jim Blanton 3.45 40/100% | Coby Alcantara | StrongStrut STB
|
Appreciate
0
|
10-18-2013, 06:05 PM | #7 |
Second Lieutenant
13
Rep 279
Posts |
I was just joking!!!
But that's a good answer.
__________________
06 Alpinweiss Z4M R Anthracite Apex EC-7 9F/9.5R, 245/275 Super Sport's, 17" Kosei K1 255/40r17 Direzza II, SS Lines, Pagid RS29, Ate SuperBlue, VT Comp. MM's, RE trans. mounts, AST 4150, Swift springs, Vorschlag camber plates, RE RSM, H&R swaybars, spherical rtabs, SuperFlex poly fcabs, StrongStrut Braces, Euro Headers, Stromung exhaust, ESS Tune, Eventuri intake |
Appreciate
0
|
10-18-2013, 06:20 PM | #8 |
Colonel
188
Rep 2,138
Posts
Drives: Me
Join Date: Oct 2007
Location: Virginia Beach
|
Well, I use Redline 15W50. The engine runs cooler and for a side benefit I get 1-1.8 MPG better gas mileage on the highway.
I just got done pulling the oil pan to retrieve a valve shim. I also pulled an oil sample at the same time. This will be the first oil sample since I had my rod bearings changed 4000 miles ago... This starts the new baseline and time will tell.. I had nine track days on this oil. |
Appreciate
0
|
10-18-2013, 06:22 PM | #9 | |
Bad Lieutenant
233
Rep 3,517
Posts |
Quote:
__________________
02 E39M5 | TiAg/Schwartz | Tubi Rumore | Ultimate Ti Pedals | E60 SSK | Jim Blanton 3.45 40/100% | Coby Alcantara | StrongStrut STB
Last edited by thekurgan; 10-18-2013 at 06:24 PM.. Reason: can't spell for shit |
|
Appreciate
0
|
10-19-2013, 07:39 AM | #10 |
Colonel
188
Rep 2,138
Posts
Drives: Me
Join Date: Oct 2007
Location: Virginia Beach
|
Heat is not the issue. On the street, the engine oil temperatures always stay between 195-200 even if ambient air is 99'. On the track, the engine oil temperatures stays between 200-215. ONCE I saw temps go to 220 but ambient air was 105'. The two different engine cooling systems are more than capable of removing the heat. This only goes for a normally aspirated engine. The reason for using a lighter viscosity oil (a 50 vs. 60) is that it flows better.
Also, in all the research I have done on engine oil for the S54 indicates that TWS is not as good as Redline and will actually shear down much faster than other synthetics. Since most of use are not going to fix the main issue, that is the bearings are just too narrow, we are going to use band-aid fixes like coated bearings and different weights of oil. |
Appreciate
0
|
10-19-2013, 09:29 AM | #11 |
First Lieutenant
37
Rep 398
Posts |
__________________
BSM Z4M Coupe
|
Appreciate
0
|
10-19-2013, 10:26 AM | #12 |
Colonel
1567
Rep 2,665
Posts |
I will stick with 10W60 as I haven't seen much of a reason to switch to some other weight. The idea that some have switched and not seen a problem doesn't me mean much to me. The sample size and data is lacking. I also don't see a lot of reason for BMW to initially require it if there wasn't at least a decent reason to do it.
I am considering switching to another brand as I haven't seen any proof that Castol is better than the rest. Yes BMW was part of the development of it but I think the best outcome possible was Castrol made the best oil they they could produce and it was satisfactory to BMW, doesn't mean others couldn't do better.
__________________
2006 Z4M Coupe - Stromung exhaust, ZHP knob, stubby antenna, clutch delay delete
|
Appreciate
0
|
10-19-2013, 10:34 AM | #13 | |
Bad Lieutenant
233
Rep 3,517
Posts |
Quote:
__________________
02 E39M5 | TiAg/Schwartz | Tubi Rumore | Ultimate Ti Pedals | E60 SSK | Jim Blanton 3.45 40/100% | Coby Alcantara | StrongStrut STB
|
|
Appreciate
0
|
10-19-2013, 11:24 AM | #14 |
Colonel
188
Rep 2,138
Posts
Drives: Me
Join Date: Oct 2007
Location: Virginia Beach
|
When the S54 was originally released, it used 5W30. It was only after the bearing issues was the specification changed to 10W60.
Here is the link to the spreadsheet data I was able to find (and is still looking for) on engine oil and trans/diff oil. http://www.shipkiller.com:8080/10W60-Oil_Specs.xlsx |
Appreciate
0
|
10-19-2013, 03:26 PM | #15 |
Lieutenant Colonel
80
Rep 1,663
Posts |
To me the biggest question is, which oil is better to prevent bearing issues?
__________________
|
Appreciate
0
|
10-19-2013, 04:45 PM | #16 |
Colonel
188
Rep 2,138
Posts
Drives: Me
Join Date: Oct 2007
Location: Virginia Beach
|
Well, I don't think there is a 100% sure fire answer since the underlying bearing issue is a design issue (the bearings are too narrow), but I do not subscribe to the 'the BMW engineers know more than you' response.
In May at VIR, I had a discussion with James Clay (Bimmerworld) and he related to us standing around that they (Bimmerworld) has seen much better rod bearing wear by switching to 15W50 vice 10W60. Now this was primarily on the race cars but you could extrapolate the data back to a street car, and since they tear down their engines much more frequently than we do, they do have the data. I had been thinking along these lines for a while now, but this new data was the push I needed to do the change. Since my rod bearings were just changed (4K ago) and I just pulled an oil sample, this resets all my data and I will be able to tell if it does any good or not. |
Appreciate
0
|
10-19-2013, 05:10 PM | #17 | |
Colonel
1567
Rep 2,665
Posts |
Quote:
Seems unlikely to me that after 12 years of recommending the 10W60 (not sure on dates) that BMW engineers wouldn't have realized that the 15W50 works better, again speculation. Also, I generally prefer to follow manufacturers recommendations unless there is good data or proof showing something else is better. The whole "use Castrol only" is a little different because I don't believe they tested any brands that might be better because of this partnership.
__________________
2006 Z4M Coupe - Stromung exhaust, ZHP knob, stubby antenna, clutch delay delete
|
|
Appreciate
0
|
10-19-2013, 05:49 PM | #18 | |
Colonel
188
Rep 2,138
Posts
Drives: Me
Join Date: Oct 2007
Location: Virginia Beach
|
Quote:
I do not think there is a 'right' answer to this oil question. I just changed based on oiling principles and others who do know more than I do, not to steer me wrong. We shall see. The proof will be in the Blackstone reports. Of course, I do not subscribe to the 15K oil change intervals that BMW recommends either. |
|
Appreciate
0
|
10-19-2013, 05:56 PM | #19 |
Dog Listener
707
Rep 7,850
Posts |
^ +1
Excellent reasoning and agree with the points noted. Since, as you say, it's a design issue we're really chasing options not total solutions (fix the crank/bearing/design). |
Appreciate
0
|
10-20-2013, 10:58 AM | #20 | |
Colonel
1567
Rep 2,665
Posts |
Quote:
I also agree about the decisions not always being decided based on longevity. If longevity was the most important factor all car manuals would say "for maximum longevity use synthetic motor oil". I have never read anything that disputes this, only that the average consumer probably won't keep the car long enough for it to matter to them and that it costs more up front.
__________________
2006 Z4M Coupe - Stromung exhaust, ZHP knob, stubby antenna, clutch delay delete
|
|
Appreciate
0
|
10-20-2013, 11:02 AM | #21 |
Colonel
188
Rep 2,138
Posts
Drives: Me
Join Date: Oct 2007
Location: Virginia Beach
|
|
Appreciate
0
|
10-20-2013, 11:39 PM | #22 |
First Lieutenant
11
Rep 304
Posts |
Interesting. At least it gives people options. For me, I put 135k on my E46M3 and my 06MR is up to 75k with the Castrol TWS doing 15k changes.
I am not at all saying that mid-cycle changes aren't good and that alternative oil options might not be better, but for me I will stick with what has worked mile after mile. |
Appreciate
0
|
Post Reply |
Bookmarks |
|
|