|
|
SUPPORT ZPOST BY DOING YOUR TIRERACK SHOPPING FROM THIS BANNER, THANKS! |
Post Reply |
|
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
09-03-2014, 05:01 PM | #1 |
New Member
8
Rep 17
Posts |
DILEMMA: E85 Z4 3.0i or 986 Boxster S??
Hi all,
I'm in a dilemma right now trying to choose between an e85 z4 3.0i (2006 and newer) and a 986 porsche boxster S (2001 and newer). I'm sure some of you guys have had similar thoughts while choosing your zed's, so I thought I'd ask for some input. Now before gets on my case about using the search feature, I know that there was another thread going around about these two cars but they mostly compared it with the Z4 M, which doesn't help since it's a little out of my budget So if you guys could stick to comparing it to the 3.0i, I'd greatly appreciate it Below are the factors for my considerations (both prices are relatively the same): Z4 3.0i (2006 and newer) PROS - newer, nicer interior and exterior, I own an e46 right so am somewhat more familiar with mechanics/maintenance work CONS - not as fast (but fast enough), no premium sound, not as much luggage room Boxster S (2001 and newer) PROS - it's a Porsche, faster/bigger engine, premium bose sound, this is the S (or in BMW terms "M") version, has more luggage room CONS - older, interior looks outdated, no cup holders (!), more difficult/pricey to maintain, never owned a porsche so not too familiar with typical symptoms Thanks in advance! |
09-03-2014, 06:41 PM | #2 |
///Multiple
2992
Rep 4,243
Posts
Drives: M4 Coupe | M3 | Z4M Roadster
Join Date: Jan 2011
Location: San Diego, CA
iTrader: (1)
Garage List 2006 BMW Z4 M Roadster [8.81]
2016 BMW M4 Coupe ( ... [10.00] 2018 BMW M3 (Euro D ... [0.00] 2011 BMW 335is Coup ... [10.00] |
Z4 3.0i
Pro: You can hang out here with the rest of the Z4 crowd Boxster S Con: You won't be able to hang out here (well you could, but what would be the point?) I'm kind of wondering why you're not considering a newer non-S Boxster, which would be more apples to apples with the Z4 3.0i. What is your budget?
__________________
The Coupe: 2016 M4 | Sakhir Orange | Black Full Merino Leather | CF Trim | M-DCT | More | ED 5/13/16
The Sedan: 2018 M3 | San Marino Blue | Black Full Merino Leather | CF Trim | M-DCT | ZCP | ED 7/18/18 The Roadster: 2006 Z4 | Interlagos Blue | Black Extended Nappa Leather | Carbon Leather Trim | Purchased 7/19/12 |
Appreciate
0
|
09-03-2014, 06:52 PM | #3 |
Colonel
479
Rep 2,782
Posts
Drives: ESS/G-Power Z4M, VF Z4, 996tt
Join Date: Sep 2009
Location: Los Angeles
|
Google "Porsche IMS engine failure".
The post-facelift non-M Z4 is a very solid car with few common, major issues.
__________________
|
Appreciate
0
|
09-04-2014, 12:29 AM | #4 | |
New Member
8
Rep 17
Posts |
Quote:
|
|
Appreciate
0
|
09-04-2014, 12:44 AM | #5 | |
New Member
8
Rep 17
Posts |
Quote:
Nonetheless, issues like these are one of the reasons why I am hesitating on choosing the boxster. Fixing those are priiiicaayyyyy |
|
Appreciate
0
|
09-04-2014, 02:11 AM | #6 | |
///Multiple
2992
Rep 4,243
Posts
Drives: M4 Coupe | M3 | Z4M Roadster
Join Date: Jan 2011
Location: San Diego, CA
iTrader: (1)
Garage List 2006 BMW Z4 M Roadster [8.81]
2016 BMW M4 Coupe ( ... [10.00] 2018 BMW M3 (Euro D ... [0.00] 2011 BMW 335is Coup ... [10.00] |
Quote:
I think that you're comparing apples and oranges, comparing a Boxster S to a non-M Z4.
__________________
The Coupe: 2016 M4 | Sakhir Orange | Black Full Merino Leather | CF Trim | M-DCT | More | ED 5/13/16
The Sedan: 2018 M3 | San Marino Blue | Black Full Merino Leather | CF Trim | M-DCT | ZCP | ED 7/18/18 The Roadster: 2006 Z4 | Interlagos Blue | Black Extended Nappa Leather | Carbon Leather Trim | Purchased 7/19/12 |
|
Appreciate
1
GMe90356.00 |
09-04-2014, 02:58 AM | #7 |
Rookie
33
Rep 379
Posts |
Aside from both being 2 seater drop-tops, they are totally different cars. Have you driven both? I personally like how the Boxster handles better than the Z4 but couldn't stomach the look.
__________________
2003 Z4 2.5i
2013 FR-S 1990 911 C2 1983 Wife |
Appreciate
0
|
09-04-2014, 05:48 AM | #8 | |
#buildnotbought
10906
Rep 4,901
Posts |
Quote:
Not as serious as the ims bearing.....(which is NOT caused by grandma style driving.... It's a worn ball bearing!) Also the boxster engine can suffer from cracked blocks (like the 996). That is a major disaster ofcourse. Compared to the bmw engines, the porsche engines have major problems. But I can't see how to compare the boxster-s to a z4 3.0i (even an 3.0si) The z4 is much newer/lower mileage or much cheaper.
__________________
Z4 3.0i | ESS TS2+ supercharger | Quaife ATB LSD | Brembo/BMW performance BBK front/rear | Schrick FI cams | Schmiedmann headers+cats | Powerflex/strongflex PU bushings | Vibra-technics engine mounts | H&R anti rollbars | KW V3 coilovers/KW camber plates | Sachs race engineering clutch | tons of custom sh#t
|
|
Appreciate
0
|
09-04-2014, 06:58 AM | #9 |
Brigadier General
851
Rep 4,057
Posts |
Get a Z4 3.0si or a Z4M and be done with it. The Boxster is a mighty fine car but I would not sleep nights for worry of an IMS failure.
And I think some Z4's came with a decent enough stereo. Mine can certainly belt it out, let me tell you.
__________________
Huz-Z
BMW Z4 3.0si Roadster. Montego Blue Metallic. Premium and Sport Package. |
Appreciate
0
|
09-04-2014, 07:23 AM | #10 |
Second Lieutenant
25
Rep 204
Posts |
Can't speak for the S, but the boxster is a very precise handling car while the z is a bit more wild - it's not going to be as sharp as the boxster but it's a huge amount of fun around the twisties.
I use mine as a daily (except in snow) and also in autocross and the Z 3.0 is great in both. Winding the N52 up like spooling up a jet engine- extremely smooth. The Z is more of a handful in autocross and I'm just learning to control it now, but it's a lot of fun. It's nice to be able to oversteer with the push of the throttle! Plus the people on this forum are awesome. Drive both and pick the one you like best! -gc |
Appreciate
0
|
09-04-2014, 09:28 AM | #11 |
Gone but not forgotten
4
Rep 148
Posts |
I would buy a 3.0si. The Porsche and Z4 are very different cars. I was in your boat about 4 years ago and opted for the BMW Z43.0si. It was a great car and great fun. I since have been able to afford the 981 Porsche and between the 981 and current Z4, at the risk of getting flamed, the 981 Porsche is the most fun you can have with your pants on.
__________________
2015 Audi SQ5
RECENT PAST 2013 Porsche Boxster S 2009 335i/Coupe/Dinan S3 2006 BMW Z4 3.0si Last edited by Lark; 09-04-2014 at 09:36 AM.. |
Appreciate
0
|
09-04-2014, 09:29 AM | #12 |
Lieutenant
67
Rep 501
Posts |
Have you driven the Boxster S?
I have, and REALLY disliked it. Steering/handling might be "precise" but power is not impressive, the shifter and clutch are absurdly terrible, and the interior does not age well. |
Appreciate
0
|
09-04-2014, 09:37 AM | #13 |
Gone but not forgotten
4
Rep 148
Posts |
I assume you are talking about the 986 because I have to respectfully disagree with respect to 981. That is why I recommended the Z4 for the age and price of vehicle the OP is focusing on.
__________________
2015 Audi SQ5
RECENT PAST 2013 Porsche Boxster S 2009 335i/Coupe/Dinan S3 2006 BMW Z4 3.0si |
Appreciate
0
|
09-04-2014, 12:36 PM | #14 | |
Lieutenant General
2289
Rep 12,565
Posts
Drives: Z4 M, X5, GX460
Join Date: Apr 2008
Location: CT
iTrader: (99)
Garage List F15 X5 xDrive35i [8.75]
E86 Z4 M [10.00] F10 550i (Retired) [9.17] F25 X3 xDrive35i (R ... [9.43] E82 135is (Retired) [9.50] E85 Z4 M (Retired) [9.41] E90 328i xDrive (Re ... [9.25] E86 Z4 3.0si (Retired) [9.24] |
Quote:
Between 987 Spyder and 981 S, it's a toss up for me. Add few options to the 981 and the used Spyder will be far cheaper though. |
|
Appreciate
0
|
09-04-2014, 01:02 PM | #15 |
#dubspec
6337
Rep 5,201
Posts |
i would go for a z4. there is a red supercharged z4m roadtser for sale here for 24k i beileve. that will blow your pants off. look up user nekky
__________________
LCI ///F80 M3 Individual Atlantis Metallic / Black Full / Carbon Cermics / 6MT
MPE / M Performance & Carbon package / KW v3 / 20" HRE R101LW / 20" HRE 527s / Michelin PSS / 20% tint / 3d Design / Streckenn splitters / OEM GTS hood / EAS Carbon seatbacks / Carbon RKP sideskirt / Bootmod3 / M Performance Tri color alcantara / AWE S Flow instagram: @ dubsesd |
Appreciate
0
|
09-04-2014, 01:15 PM | #16 |
Midlife Crises Racing Silent but Deadly Class
1821
Rep 5,337
Posts
Drives: 2006 MZ4C, 2021 Tesla Model 3
Join Date: Oct 2007
Location: Welcome to Jamaica have a nice day
|
Boxster S hands down for me.
I'm waiting for either 991 GT3 or 991 Turbo to come down enough in price to pick one up. Which means in about 10 years or so I'll be rocking a Porsche...Just in time for my daughter to go to college.
__________________
Sitting on a beat-up office chair in front of a 5 year old computer in a basement floor, sipping on stale coffee watching a bunch of meaningless numbers scrolling aimlessly on a dimly lit 19” monitor.
|
Appreciate
0
|
09-04-2014, 03:01 PM | #17 |
#dubspec
6337
Rep 5,201
Posts |
My friends 986 boxster s is in the shop for ims issues and coolant mixing with his oil issues. Also a pain to work on. Literally can't see the motor without taking the car apart. 911 is a different story. My future dream is a 997.2 turbo or gt3 hopefully
__________________
LCI ///F80 M3 Individual Atlantis Metallic / Black Full / Carbon Cermics / 6MT
MPE / M Performance & Carbon package / KW v3 / 20" HRE R101LW / 20" HRE 527s / Michelin PSS / 20% tint / 3d Design / Streckenn splitters / OEM GTS hood / EAS Carbon seatbacks / Carbon RKP sideskirt / Bootmod3 / M Performance Tri color alcantara / AWE S Flow instagram: @ dubsesd |
Appreciate
0
|
09-04-2014, 03:24 PM | #18 | |
Gone but not forgotten
4
Rep 148
Posts |
Quote:
It is bizarre having a car which you cannot see any part of the engine from above. You get some funny looks from people as you load things into the trunk and frunk with no engine in sight.
__________________
2015 Audi SQ5
RECENT PAST 2013 Porsche Boxster S 2009 335i/Coupe/Dinan S3 2006 BMW Z4 3.0si |
|
Appreciate
0
|
09-04-2014, 03:39 PM | #19 |
Lieutenant
67
Rep 501
Posts |
Correct, I've never driven the 981. The 987 and 986 Boxsters/Caymans along with the 996 Carrerras that I've driven have all shared the same characteristics that I don't like... Maybe I'm just not a Porsche guy.
|
Appreciate
0
|
09-04-2014, 03:44 PM | #20 |
Gone but not forgotten
4
Rep 148
Posts |
Maybe not and that's fair. Different strokes for different folks. If we all liked the same thing there would only be 1 car manufacturer and 1 car. But before you completely write Porsche off, drive the 981.
__________________
2015 Audi SQ5
RECENT PAST 2013 Porsche Boxster S 2009 335i/Coupe/Dinan S3 2006 BMW Z4 3.0si |
Appreciate
0
|
09-04-2014, 03:53 PM | #21 |
Lieutenant Colonel
140
Rep 1,991
Posts |
I had a 2002 986 2.7. Amazing car. The handling was superior to the Z4M I drive now, but the overall experience is made up for by the S54 power plant. I don't care for the electric steering on the non M Z4's.
Last edited by chickdr; 09-05-2014 at 07:36 AM.. |
Appreciate
0
|
09-04-2014, 04:10 PM | #22 |
#buildnotbought
10906
Rep 4,901
Posts |
That can be a faulty head gasket but also a cracked block/cilinder head, which is a known issue for these engines and very $$$$
__________________
Z4 3.0i | ESS TS2+ supercharger | Quaife ATB LSD | Brembo/BMW performance BBK front/rear | Schrick FI cams | Schmiedmann headers+cats | Powerflex/strongflex PU bushings | Vibra-technics engine mounts | H&R anti rollbars | KW V3 coilovers/KW camber plates | Sachs race engineering clutch | tons of custom sh#t
|
Appreciate
0
|
Post Reply |
Bookmarks |
Tags |
3.0i, 986, boxster s, compare, e85 |
|
|