View Single Post
      08-16-2015, 02:26 PM   #7
Arsonism
Captain
Arsonism's Avatar
United_States
158
Rep
747
Posts

Drives: '08 M Coupe
Join Date: Oct 2013
Location: Austin, TX

iTrader: (3)

Quote:
Originally Posted by pokeybritches View Post
That's very unfortunate. Sorry to hear it!

I haven't spent an extensive amount of time searching, but the thought of being forced to replace an engine has crossed my mind. The S54 has numerous fatal flaws. I would be hesitant to buy a used engine from anyone other than a reputable shop. I have seen S54's for sale from Lang Racing for around $6k.

If you don't have that kind of money available, there are other ways to get you back on the road, or get the car to a condition where you could sell it. Besides a personal loan (double digit interest rate), you can take out a car loan for more than what you currently owe assuming you owe less than what the car is worth (basically taking equity out on the car, and obviously you pay your current loan off with the new loan). While it's not ideal, sometimes people get stuck. Some banks will only lend you what you currently owe. The Z4M is an older used car, and interest rates can vary significantly. Each time you apply for a loan, it's marked on your credit report.

I was a year away from paying off my first car and had a change in life conditions. I tried to do the smart thing and sell the car. Unfortunately the car was worth more to me than I was offered on trade in, and a private sale might have taken some time. I applied for a loan with a different bank, and ultimately extended the one year of payments I had left into two. I kept the cash as an emergency fund. My interest rate was reduced with the new loan (since I was young and had no credit history when I got the first loan), so it was almost like a net interest-free loan. Fortunately everything worked out and the cash sat in savings while the circumstances passed.

The point is, refinancing is a secondary option if you don't have the liquid assets to repair the car the right way. It may allow you to keep your savings as an emergency fund in case you're laid off, but it will increase the amount you need to stay afloat every month. A Z4M isn't a car that sells quickly. It needs the right buyer, especially if it needs a new engine. So, you may not be able to pull the equity from the car with an outright sale should dire circumstances arise.

I wouldn't advise depleting your emergency fund to fix the car. Personal loans have ridiculous interest rates, so I'd keep that option as a last resort. My advice - refinance, and use the money to fix the car. Cross your fingers and hope things turn around at work. If you get laid off, immediately put the car up for sale.

What does your insurance company say?

I put 10k down on her when I picked her up and definitely don't owe the entire amount of the car now. It was appraised somewhere around 29,850 when I refinanced about six months ago and I owe around 16-17 if I remember right.

The only issue is that I've already been laid off, I'm currently on the job hunt without a lead currently. I'll be reducing my rent and a few other things here shortly, but outside of that I'm not sure what they'll look at doing for me. It does happen to be a local federal credit union though so I'll check up with them. I really appreciate your insight here, this was something I had not thought of.

I'm looking into Lang Racing now but I don't think they have anything directly for sale and I'm unsure how they treat core exchanges or what have you. I'll update this is as I go along through the process if that's something that I decide to move forward with. Once again, I sincerely appreciate your suggestions here. If there are any other companies that specialize in these engines and the rebuilding of them or even just would have some reputable used motors on hand, I would greatly appreciate the leads as I started out with something as simple as ebay.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Westersund View Post
Just a theory here, can you get a look at the crank shaft? If it's blueish in color were the cylinder wall and piston broke maybe the shop doing the rod bearing replacement tightened that rod bearing too much, or used the wrong thickness of rod bearing, causing too much friction and heat that transfered to the cylinder wall and piston. As I said, just a theory.
Unfortunately I didn't get a good look at the crank. The lower block had everything together on it and the head had been pulled off. I actually looked over it real quick but I diverted straight to the cylinder with the cracks as I was still in disbelief that something like that could have happened. I could ask the shop for some photos to see if they could determine more.




Hopefully this gal isn't out of the running just yet.
Appreciate 0