[gtMc]

Tony, are you a cca member? If so, perrhaps reaching out to the dealer ombudsmen wouldn't hurt from the Nj chapter? This sounds like its gotten way beyond where it should have. Agree with everything folks have said here, they should be honoring the warranty without question. Accepting anything less is not right, especially because your actions haven't voided the warranty.

Disgusting that bmw is making this so difficult. There is another dealership in the area that you might try going thru as well... and I know the Nj cca member who handles relations with them there. Happy to send an Email if you'd like?